
Old Shale Knit Stitch Pattern (Feather and Fan Stitch): Easy Lace Knitting Tutorial — Turquoise with Vanilla
Few knitting stitches carry as much history, elegance, and effortless beauty as the Old Shale stitch. Also known as Feather and Fan, this classic lace pattern has been worked by knitters for centuries, flowing from the hands of Shetland island women into the modern knitting world where it continues to enchant beginners and experienced crafters alike. If you’ve ever admired the rhythmic, shell-like waves of a lace shawl or scarf and wondered whether you could recreate it yourself, the answer is a resounding yes — and this tutorial will show you exactly how.
Today we’re diving into a particularly fresh and cheerful colorway: turquoise paired with vanilla. This combination gives the pattern a coastal, summery feel without veering into anything too bold or busy. The pale cream of vanilla allows the lace structure to breathe while the turquoise adds that pop of color that makes the finished piece feel intentional and polished. Whether you’re knitting a scarf, a baby blanket, a shawl, or a simple swatch to practice the technique, this color pairing is a joy to work with.
Let’s start at the beginning.
What Is the Old Shale Stitch?
The Old Shale stitch — sometimes written as “ole shale” in older pattern books — is a traditional Shetland lace pattern that produces a series of gentle, undulating waves. The name itself is a little mysterious; some knitters believe “shale” refers to the shell-like shape the waves create, reminiscent of scalloped edges found along shorelines. Others think it’s simply a corruption of an older word. Whatever its origins, the stitch has proven timeless.
In modern knitting, you’ll often see it referred to as the Feather and Fan stitch, though technically purists draw a subtle distinction between the two: traditional Old Shale tends to use a four-row repeat with a slightly different arrangement of yarn-overs and decreases, while Feather and Fan can vary slightly depending on the source. For the purposes of this tutorial, we’ll use the terms interchangeably, as they produce essentially the same visual effect and the same satisfying wave pattern.
What makes Old Shale so popular among knitters of all skill levels is its combination of visual complexity and actual simplicity. Looking at it, you’d think it must require intricate lace charts and years of experience. In reality, once you understand the four-row repeat, the pattern practically knits itself. It’s the kind of stitch that keeps your hands busy without demanding your full concentration — perfect for knitting while watching a film or listening to a podcast.
Why Turquoise and Vanilla?
Color choices in knitting matter enormously. The wrong colorway can muddy even the most beautiful stitch structure, while the right pairing can make a simple pattern sing.
Turquoise and vanilla work so well together for several reasons. First, they share a certain lightness — turquoise, when chosen in a medium or slightly muted tone rather than a neon shade, has a fresh clarity to it that complements the soft warmth of vanilla. They don’t compete with each other. Instead, the vanilla gives the eye a place to rest while the turquoise provides visual interest.
Second, this combination has remarkable versatility. A turquoise and vanilla scarf or shawl can work for spring and summer as easily as it transitions into the cooler months when layered over warmer clothing. A baby blanket in these colors is universally appealing — bright enough to be cheerful, soft enough to feel gentle.
Third, when you knit the Old Shale pattern in a single color (whether turquoise or vanilla), the wave structure itself becomes the star. When you stripe the two colors through the four-row repeat — which this tutorial will cover — you get a piece that looks striped and lacy simultaneously, with waves of color rolling through the fabric like actual ocean waves. It’s genuinely one of the prettiest effects in simple knitting.
Materials You’ll Need
Before casting on, gather your supplies. The beauty of Old Shale is that it works with virtually any yarn weight, though the gauge will obviously change your finished dimensions. For a beginner-friendly project with good stitch definition, a DK weight or light worsted weight yarn is ideal.
For this turquoise and vanilla project, here’s what you’ll want to have ready:
Your yarn in turquoise and vanilla — choose a smooth yarn rather than a fuzzy or heavily textured one, as lace stitches need clean, defined strands for the eyelets to show clearly. Pure wool, wool blends, cotton, and cotton blends all work beautifully. A high-twist yarn will give especially crisp stitch definition.
Knitting needles in the size recommended for your yarn, or one size larger if you want a more open, drapey fabric. Lace generally benefits from needles sized slightly larger than you might use for stockinette in the same yarn, as this allows the eyelets to open up properly.
A tapestry needle for weaving in your ends when you switch colors.
Scissors.
Stitch markers are optional but can be helpful when you’re first learning the pattern, as they let you mark the boundaries of each pattern repeat.
Understanding the Stitch Repeat
Old Shale is built on a multiple of 18 stitches, which is the most commonly used version of this pattern. Some variations use 12-stitch repeats, but the 18-stitch repeat gives the fullest, most pronounced waves. When planning your project, cast on a multiple of 18. If you’re adding a border or selvage stitches, add those separately.
For a practice swatch, cast on 36 stitches (two full repeats). This gives you enough width to see the wave pattern develop properly without making an enormous swatch.
The pattern unfolds over four rows, which constitute one complete repeat of the wave:
Row 1 (right side): Knit all stitches.
Row 2: Purl all stitches.
Row 3: This is the pattern row — the one where all the magic happens. Working across your stitches, you’ll work the following sequence across each 18-stitch repeat: knit 2 together three times, then yarn over and knit 1 six times, then knit 2 together three times. This creates the decreases that form the valleys and the yarn-overs that form the peaks.
Row 4: Knit all stitches.
That’s the entire pattern. Four rows, one design row, and the rest are simply knit and purl. Once you’ve completed these four rows a handful of times, you’ll find that your fingers learn the rhythm and you can work Row 3 from memory without even thinking about it.
Step-by-Step: Working the Pattern Row
Row 3 deserves a closer look, especially for those who are newer to lace knitting. Let’s walk through it in detail.
When you reach the beginning of a new 18-stitch repeat, you’ll start with your decreases. Knit 2 together three times: insert your right needle tip through the next two stitches on your left needle simultaneously, then knit them as one stitch. You’ve decreased by one stitch. Repeat this two more times. You’ve now consumed six stitches and have produced three, netting a decrease of three stitches in this section.
Next come your yarn-overs. Bring the working yarn forward between your needles, then take it over the top of the right needle to the back. This creates a new stitch — a loop on the right needle — without knitting into anything. Then knit 1. Repeat this sequence (yarn over, knit 1) a total of six times. You’ve now added six new stitches, which exactly compensates for the six decreases coming at the end.
Finally, knit 2 together three more times, just as you did at the beginning. This creates the symmetry that forms the wave: decreases on both ends, increases in the middle.
When you look at your knitting after completing a few repeats, you’ll see those six yarn-overs clustered together in the center of each repeat creating an arc of eyelets — the crest of the wave — flanked by the smoother, decrease-shaped edges on either side.
Introducing the Two Colors
Here’s where the turquoise and vanilla combination really comes to life. The simplest way to work two colors in Old Shale is to change colors every four rows — that is, every complete pattern repeat.
Work rows 1 through 4 in turquoise. At the end of Row 4, drop the turquoise and pick up vanilla. Work rows 1 through 4 in vanilla. Drop the vanilla and pick up turquoise again. Continue in this way throughout your project.
Because you’re always changing at the end of Row 4 (or the beginning of Row 1), you’re always starting each new color on the right side of your work, which keeps the color transitions clean and consistent. The yarn you’ve dropped will be waiting at the edge of your work and can simply be carried up the side for the next time you need it, as long as the stripes are narrow enough. Since you’re working four-row stripes, you can carry the yarn comfortably up the side without it pulling or creating visible loops.
The effect this produces is extraordinary for how simple it is. Because Row 3 — the pattern row with all the yarn-overs — is worked in a single color, each wave of eyelets belongs clearly to either turquoise or vanilla, and the two colors roll through the fabric in alternating bands that mirror the wave structure perfectly.
If you want subtler color transitions, you can also try changing colors every eight rows (two full repeats per color), which produces wider stripes and a slightly calmer effect. Or for something more unexpected, try making the turquoise stripes twice as wide as the vanilla ones — three pattern repeats of turquoise to one of vanilla. The asymmetry creates its own visual interest.
Finishing Your Project
Once you’ve reached the desired length or completed your final pattern repeat, you’ll want to bind off in a way that preserves the wave shape of the fabric. A standard knit bind-off works perfectly for this pattern. Bind off loosely — using a needle one or two sizes larger than you’ve been knitting with is a helpful trick — to keep the cast-off edge from pulling in and distorting your beautiful waves.
After binding off, weave in all your ends using your tapestry needle. Because you’ve been carrying the yarn up the side, you’ll have relatively few ends to deal with, which is one of the pleasant efficiencies of this approach to colorwork.
Blocking is the final and arguably the most transformative step in any lace project. Wet blocking — soaking your finished piece in cool water for about twenty minutes, pressing out the excess water gently in a towel, and then pinning it out to the desired dimensions on a blocking board or mat — opens up the eyelets dramatically and sets the wave shape beautifully. The difference between a blocked and unblocked Old Shale piece can be startling. What looks like a slightly rumpled fabric before blocking becomes a graceful, flowing piece of lace once it has been pinned out and dried. Don’t skip this step.
Allow your piece to dry completely before unpinning. Natural fibers may take a day or two in a well-ventilated room.
Project Ideas for Old Shale in Turquoise and Vanilla
The versatility of this stitch means it suits a wide range of projects. Here are some ideas to inspire your next cast-on.
A simple infinity scarf or rectangular scarf worked in DK weight yarn with a cast-on of 36 stitches (two repeats) and knitted until you reach a comfortable length makes a perfect beginner project. The narrow width keeps the project quick and manageable while giving you plenty of time to learn the rhythm of the repeat.
A baby blanket in Old Shale is a classic project that has delighted knitters for generations. Using a soft cotton or cotton-blend yarn in turquoise and vanilla, cast on 108 stitches (six repeats) and work until the blanket is square. The result is a heirloom-quality piece that any new parent would treasure.
A lightweight shawl or shawlette worked in fingering weight yarn with a 90-stitch cast-on (five repeats) creates something exquisitely delicate. Fingering weight opens the lace even further and gives the waves a gossamer quality. Block it generously and the eyelets will sparkle.
A table runner in cotton yarn brings the stitch into your home décor. Worked in turquoise and vanilla, it would complement a coastal or Scandinavian-inspired interior beautifully.
Even a simple dishcloth in worsted cotton gives you a chance to practice the stitch while producing something immediately useful.
Tips for Success
A few final thoughts to help you get the most out of this pattern:
Counting your stitches after Row 3 is essential, especially when you’re first learning. The row should produce the same stitch count it started with, since the yarn-overs and decreases cancel each other out. If your count is off, it’s much easier to catch the mistake immediately than after you’ve knitted Row 4 and are ready to move on.
Working with two separate balls of yarn from the start makes color changes smooth and stress-free. Wind a small butterfly of vanilla yarn if you prefer working from a center-pull ball, or simply let the vanilla sit beside your turquoise as you work.
If you find the yarn-overs on Row 3 feel awkward or keep sliding off your needle, try working more deliberately and keeping your tension slightly looser than usual on that row. It gets easier with practice.
Take photographs of your work from above every few pattern repeats. Old Shale photographs beautifully, and you’ll want to document how the waves build and the colors interact.
Most importantly, enjoy the process. Old Shale is the kind of pattern that rewards you generously for very little effort. There’s a deep satisfaction in seeing those waves emerge from what feels like simple, repetitive motion — the same satisfaction Shetland knitters have been experiencing for centuries. In turquoise and vanilla, it’s a combination as fresh and timeless as the stitch itself, and with a little patience and a pair of needles, it’s entirely within your reach.
Happy knitting.